Score: 9

"Excelent beneath the surface"

submission: |~Snow Snow For Lucy~|

date: 1 hour ago

While the trailer was far from impressive, the actual deal was excellent. While the technicalities could clearly have been improved, that matters little. The real content is not that, the real content is the art that you drew, and most importantly the story that you wrote. It has hearth, it has natural, yet strong emotions. I could barely hold my tears, the story is just that good.

Score: 3

"Teaches nothing"

submission: Particle Tutorial

date: December 19, 2009

This teaches nothing about the inner workings of the presented algorithms. This is just another "copy paste this code plz!" tutorial.

Score: 6

"Good concept, short execution"

submission: Christmas Uncovered

date: December 18, 2009

You really should have made this longer, this has a lot of potentional, but it's wasted by being so short.

Score: 0

"Waste of time"

submission: Chrono Trigger Opening

date: December 16, 2009

This is only 5 sec of badly ripped animation from the game. And there is no sound. There is absolutely no point in submitting this. It is not just "too short", it doesn't have any content what so ever. This is an insult to the original game.

Score: 9

"An excelent presentation"

submission: China Case Study

date: December 16, 2009

It has a very clear, yet cool style about the graphics and manages to make the facts interesting. Howerver, the music loops very badly. But the music is very good.

Score: 10

"Everything good about stick fights"

submission: Prelude to the One

date: December 16, 2009

Good music, great action, and a plot that can be excused. It had variety and did not feel one sided.

Score: 2

"Not very interesting"

submission: Not Of This World!

date: December 16, 2009

The movie was so dark that it was hard to see what was going on. The video also clearly needed to be deinterlaced. As for the plot, what plot? The music was nice, but that's about it.

Score: 6

"Good action with horrible ending"

submission: Orange Adventure Xmas

date: December 9, 2009

The action was quite good. It lacks sounds effects there. But the ending is just horrible, it takes a 180 and goes of into really immature humor. This is very jarring compared to the rest of the movie. And the ending itself is just horrible, bad art, bad humor and yeah, it's bad. The ending drags down the whole movie.

Score: 5

"Needs work"

submission: moss

date: November 20, 2009

Having no sound was a bad decision. It really helps to set the mood.
The control could also take some fixing, the de facto standard is that you have to press the jump button again to do a double jump, here you only need to hold the jump button.

Some of the levels where hard, but none was impossible, but please, don't say things like "only one try", it makes people think that they are stuck if they don't complete the level the first time.

The moving platform looked bad, the player was either levitating above it or stuck inside of it.

The graphics was ok, but a bit simple. It would have been nice with a more colorfull world instead of all this brown.

The level design felt uninspired and not taking much advantage of the existing elements, it was too plain, it needs some spices.

Score: 7

"buggy"

submission: Communist in Space

date: November 19, 2009

Simple idea, good graphics. The gameplay was a bit confusing at first, but it's easy to guess. However, it threw runtime errors at me! And not just at the loading screen. This game clearly needs to be debugged.